RTCC logo

Russia considers signing up to Kyoto Protocol extension

By Tierney Smith

Russia’s leaders are under increasing domestic pressure to sign up to a second commitment of the Kyoto Protocol (KP2) according to newspaper reports.

The Russian daily Kommersant says the government is warming to the idea of signing up to KP2, following pressure from business organisations.

Russia had previously stated it would not extend its commitments beyond the first 2008-2012 period, but Deputy prime minister Arkady Dvorkovich said on Twitter today a decision had yet to be taken, writing: “This decision has not been taken.”

Could pressure from business mean the Russian government will take a U-turn on Kyoto? (Source: World Economic Forum/Creative Commons)

The news comes a day after the latest round of UN climate talks concluded in Bangkok. Observers at the negotiations told RTCC that together with the EU, Australia, New Zealand and Ukraine could all sign up to KP2.

Russia took its time to ratify the first commitment period of the Protocol, over fears it could impact the country’s economic growth, eventually signing up on 18 November 2004.

But since then the country has benefited hugely from the Protocol’s market mechanisms, particularly Joint Implementation.

Joint Implementation

According to the website Point Carbon, Russian industrial and energy companies have been lobbying their government to sign up to KP2, which would allow them to continue to earn carbon credits for emission reduction projects under the UNFCCC’s Joint Implementation (JI) mechanism.

If Russia were not to sign up to a second commitment, companies would no longer be able to benefit from earning carbon credits for such projects. The chairman of the Least Developed Countries group Pa Ousman Jarju told RTCC that developed states (Annex I) who chose not to be part of the Kyoto Protocol ‘could forget’ about the mechanisms.

Russia also has the highest number of surplus AAUs of any country – 5.8 giga tonnes, twice the amount of the EU. AAUs are the emissions allowances which set out how much a country can pollute each year under the protocol.

If Russia were allowed to carry their surplus over to a second commitment period it would make any reduction targets in this period much easier to meet, making it in their interest to sign up to a new commitment. Negotiations into what should happen to AAUs and whether countries should be allowed to carry them over are still ongoing.

Bowing to pressure 

Yuri Fyodorov, the co-chairman of a working group from Business Russia told the paper: “The second Kyoto Protocol commitment period is in the interests of Russia and Russian business and will enable active participation, including in the establishment of a global international agreement.”

Jason Anderson, Head of EU Climate Change and Energy Policy at WWF told RTCC that while it was conceivable that these discussions he is less convinced they would carry weight in the decision making process.

“In Russia there could be any number of debates at lower levels but you do not know what will happen until President Putin decides, if it gets high enough for him to decide,” he said. “It is conceivable that these discussions are taking place but they would not be the expression of vigorous and widespread debate.

“There are certainly some people voicing these issues in Russia but whether they see results and carry the day internally is still yet to be seen.”

He said that a move such as this from Russia could be a “helpful expression” and could help the EU’s position, offering more weight to push for undecided countries such as Australia to sign up a second commitment and countries such as New Zealand and Japan to change their mind.

No announcement is expected until the UNFCCC ministerial meeting in South Korea ahead of COP18.

Related Articles:

What’s stopping Russia taking a lead at the UN climate change talks?

Read more on: |

Related News

Ghost of Kyoto Protocol haunts Russia’s energy plans

Russia threatens ‘radical measures’ in response to Kyoto Protocol extension

Russia now ‘very unlikely’ to join Kyoto extension in Doha

Russia set to link decision on Kyoto Protocol to Doha outcomes

  • Molly Millions

    guys, first of all, you all (meaning the English-speaking media) seem to misinterpret what Dvorkovich wrote in his Twitter account. “Такое решение не принималось” is actually way closer to ‘there was no such decision’. unlike your translation, this one does not heighten the expectations of an U-turn at all.
    plus, the Kommersant article in question is widely considered to be wishful thinking and, frankly, quite a stretch made in the race for the front page. the sources used in the article seem to be, like, 50 storeys lower than the only decision maker.